Do New Balance Running Shoes Run True to Size Compared to Saucony?

When comparing running shoe brands, one of the most common questions is whether sizing is consistent between them. If you already wear Saucony and are considering switching, you may be wondering if New Balance running shoes fit the same or if adjustments are needed. In most cases, both brands run true to size in length, but the overall fit can feel different due to width, toe box shape, and design philosophy. Understanding these differences is key to choosing the right size, especially when shopping online through trusted retailers like Van Dyke & Bacon. Click here to shop our New Balance collection. 

Do New Balance and Saucony Fit the Same?

The short answer is that both New Balance and Saucony generally run true to size, meaning your usual size will often work in both brands. However, how they feel on your foot can vary significantly. Saucony shoes are typically known for having a more snug, performance-oriented fit, while New Balance tends to offer a roomier feel, especially in the toe box.

In fact, Saucony models are often described as fitting narrower with a slightly tighter forefoot, while New Balance shoes are known for offering wider options and more space overall. This difference means that even if the length is the same, the fit experience can feel completely different depending on your foot shape.

Why New Balance Often Feels Different

New Balance has built a reputation around offering a variety of widths, including narrow, standard, wide, and extra-wide options. This makes the brand a go-to choice for runners who need more room or have wider feet. Because of this, many people find that New Balance shoes feel slightly more spacious compared to Saucony.

That does not mean they run large in length. Instead, the added room in the forefoot and midfoot creates a more accommodating fit. For runners who are used to the snug feel of Saucony, this can initially feel like the shoe is bigger, even when it is technically the correct size.

How Saucony Typically Fits

Saucony running shoes are generally considered true to size as well, but they often have a more streamlined, close-to-foot design. This is especially noticeable in performance and daily training models, where a secure fit is important for stability and responsiveness.

Many runners describe Saucony shoes as having a slightly narrower toe box, which can feel more locked-in compared to New Balance. For runners with narrow or average-width feet, this can be a benefit, but those with wider feet may find them a bit restrictive.

Because of this difference, some runners switching from Saucony to New Balance notice an immediate increase in comfort due to the extra room.

Should You Order the Same Size in Both?

For most people, the answer is yes, but with a few considerations. If you wear a standard width and your Saucony shoes fit comfortably, you can usually order the same size in New Balance. However, the fit may feel slightly more relaxed.

If your Saucony shoes feel tight, especially in the toe box, switching to New Balance in the same size will likely feel more comfortable without needing to size up. On the other hand, if you prefer a snug, performance fit, you may find New Balance slightly roomier than expected.

It is also worth noting that some New Balance models can run slightly small depending on the design, leading some runners to go up half a size in certain cases. This is not universal across all models, but it is something to keep in mind when trying a new shoe.

How the New Balance Fresh Foam X 860v15 Fits

The New Balance Fresh Foam X 860v15 is a great example of how the brand balances comfort, support, and fit. This model is designed as a stability running shoe, meaning it provides extra support for runners who need guidance during their stride.

In terms of sizing, the Fresh Foam X 860v15 generally runs true to size in length. What sets it apart is the availability of multiple width options, allowing runners to find a more personalized fit. This makes it especially appealing for those who have struggled to find comfortable running shoes in narrower brands.

The shoe also features a structured upper and supportive midsole, which help create a secure feel without being overly tight. Compared to a typical Saucony running shoe, the 860v15 may feel slightly more spacious in the forefoot while still maintaining stability through the midfoot.

For runners transitioning from Saucony, this can provide a noticeable improvement in comfort, especially during longer runs or all-day wear.

Key Fit Differences to Keep in Mind

While both brands are considered true to size, the main differences come down to fit and feel rather than actual length. New Balance tends to provide a more accommodating fit, while Saucony leans toward a more performance-driven, snug design.

This means that your sizing decision should depend on your foot shape and personal preference. If you value extra room and comfort, New Balance is often the better choice. If you prefer a tighter, more locked-in feel, Saucony may be more suitable.

Trying on different styles or ordering from a retailer with easy returns can help you determine which fit works best for you.

Why Foot Shape Matters More Than Brand

One of the biggest mistakes runners make is assuming that sizing is identical across brands. While length measurements may align, the shape of the shoe plays a much larger role in how it fits.

For example, runners with wider feet or higher arches often benefit from New Balance’s more accommodating design. Meanwhile, those with narrower feet may find Saucony’s snug fit more comfortable.

This is why two shoes labeled the same size can feel completely different once you put them on. Understanding your foot shape and preferences is just as important as knowing your size.

Tips for Getting the Right Fit

When switching between brands like Saucony and New Balance, it is helpful to pay attention to how your current shoes feel. If your Saucony shoes feel tight or restrictive, sticking with the same size in New Balance is usually the best move. If your current shoes already feel roomy, you may want to focus on finding a more structured New Balance model rather than sizing down.

It is also important to consider how you plan to use the shoes. Running shoes should have a small amount of extra space in the toe box to accommodate foot swelling during activity. This is another reason why New Balance’s slightly roomier fit can be beneficial.

Final Thoughts on New Balance vs Saucony Sizing

So, do New Balance running shoes run true to size compared to Saucony? In most cases, yes, but the fit will feel different. Both brands are generally consistent in length, but New Balance offers a wider, more accommodating fit, while Saucony tends to feel more narrow and performance-focused.

If you are switching from Saucony to a model like the New Balance Fresh Foam X 860v15, you can usually stick with your regular size while enjoying a bit more room and comfort. Understanding these differences will help you make a more confident purchase and ensure you find the right fit for your needs.

By shopping from a trusted source like Van Dyke & Bacon, you can explore high-quality options and find a running shoe that supports both your performance and comfort goals.